| 2008 | Patty Stas, William E. Godfrey |
| 2007 | Kristen Cordis, Trinity |
| 2006 | Sierra Branch, Siloam |
| 2005 | Amy Cleveland, Owasso |
| 2004 | Jessica Grantham, Trinity |
| 2003 | Robin Taylor, Norman |
| 2002 | Erica Mullenix, Myrtle |
| 2001 | Stephanie Orloski, Howard Weber |
| 2000 | Darla Adams, Owasso |
| 1999 | Ashley Orr, Norman |
| 1998 | Alica Hammerton, Owasso |
| 1997 | Shana Pierson, Trinity |
| 1996 | Carry Gamble, Myrtle |
| 1995 | Joy Jansen, Del City |
| 1994 | Libby Evans, Del City |
| 1993 | Shauna Stubbs, Trinity |
| 1992 | Catrina Bitner, Myrtle |
| 1991 | Mindy Hampton, Homer E. Barkley |
| 1990 | Amber Martin, Will Rogers |
| 1989 | Holly Hammert, Will Rogers |
| 1988 | Heather Nyemaster, H.G. Coad |
| 1987 | Beth Davenport, Will Rogers |
| 1986 | Alison Young, Delta |
| 1985 | Brenda Allen, Madill |
| 1984 | Ruth Edgar, Lawton |
| 1983 | Alisa Henry, Ardmore |
| 1982 | Tammy Barrett, Edmond |
| 1981 | Lory Cray, Sir Galahad |
| 1980 | Lynn Ethredge, Delta |
| 1979 | Susan Bolinger, Siloam |
| 1978 | Kim Hine, Muskogee |
| 1977 | Christi Geis, Will Rogers |
| 1976 | Janet Sadler, Shawnee |
| 1975 | Sara Kise, Cushing |
| 1974 | Margaret Swaim, Lawton |
| 1973 | Vicki McElroy, Edmond |
| 1972 | Sheila Malone, Indian |
| 1971 | Jackie Hill, Delta |
| 1970 | Rebecca Hoke, Stillwater |
| 1969 | Connie Worley, Guymon |
| 1968 | Mona Kay McNabb, Catoosa |
| 1967 | Mona Kay McNabb, Catoosa |
| 1966 | Kathleen Conley, Indian |
| 1965 | Susan Farley, Midwest City |
| 1964 | Linda Ruth Olivo, Skiatook |
| 1963 | Jeanne Dowd, Pauls Valley |
| 1962 | Shirley Rhodes, Pauls Valley |
| 1961 | Sharon Warner, Trinity |
| 1960 | Linda Robertson, Ada |
| 1959 | Lani Jane Herbeck, Sir Galahad |
| 1958 | Carole Bartlett, OMA Vedette |
| 1957 | Carol Sacra, Pauls Valley |
| 1956 | Sharon Smith, Trinity |
| 1955 | Carol Shelp, Sir Galahad |
| 1954 | Karla Edgar, Oklahoma City |
| 1953 | No Record |
| 1952 | Jean Jimerson , Miami Acacia |
| 1951 | Carlene Stoddard, Muskogee |
| 1950 | Mary Ann Dyer, Tulsa |
| 1940 - 49 | No Record |
| 1939 | Marilyn Ellis, Duncan |
| 1938 | Margaret Swain, Bartlesville |
| 1937 | Aileen McDonald, Enid |
| 1936 | Beulah Clifford, Stillwater |
| 1935 | Elosie Diamond, Holdenville |